Passages Through Time: Chronicling Users' Information Interaction History by Recording When and What They Read

Related comments:


Summary:
In this paper, Karl Gyllstrom of the University of North Carolina Computer Science Department outlines his research in building interaction history for users to improve information retrieval and characterize document activity.  His system Passages collects data from text-based desktop activities like web-page content, emails, and other files, as well as precise timing information about these items' visibility.  These data combine to provide a very detailed record of what content was viewed and when.  This record can then be used to answer user questions about their content such as, "when did I read this paper," or "which documents have I spent the most time composing?"


The system is comprised of two subsystems: the tracing subsystem for recording event streams in the GUI and filesystem, and the retrieval subsystem for handling artifact requests ("when was the last time I read this document?") and temporal retrieval ("what files did i work on the most during this time period?").  The author goes on to detail the algorithms behind these subsystems and compare it to existing approaches, which do not currently consider how long users view material and give as much weight to glanced-over pages as ones that have been thoroughly pored over.  The author's user study examined 15 participants' use of Passages over a total of 14.27 hours of activity; the results indicated that the system was well-suited to adding nuance and precision to document history requests.


Discussion:
For the super-organized, this probably a dream come true.  Being able to know which documents you were reading during a certain period of time or finding out how much time you spent reading a paper could potentially be very useful.  I found a couple of the author's assumptions about the algorithm to be somewhat ill-founded; for starters, it is based on whether content is visible as the active window.  I have a 27" monitor and frequently have multiple documents open simultaneously, with one or neither set as the active window.  I may be reading either of them but not having that time or content logged into the system because of the way Passages is set up.  This obviously isn't going to be a problem for everyone, but I feel like the productivity-hawks who would use something like this would probably have large or multiple displays, thus rendering the system less effective.